My amazing husband Joe celebrates his 30th birthday this week and to honor everything he’s done over the past 3 decades, I decided to bake him the cake of all cakes. It’s called a “Cherpumple” and we first learned about the delectably large dessert from our dear friend Noelle. A lover of cakes herself (in fact, her cake-themed birthday was featured in Rachel Ray Magazine), Noelle has been ogling the Cherpumple for quite some time.
It’s called the “Turducken of holiday desserts” and much like its meaty counterpart, the Cherpumple combines all of your favorite flavors into one enormous dish. You begin with cherry (cher), pumpkin (pum) and apple (ple) pies, which you then bake into individual layers of cake. After that, you stack the pie/cakes, frosting between each layer and cover the monstrosity with mounds of cream cheese frosting. Voila….the Cherpumple!
As you might imagine, this ridiculous dose of sugar has quite the cult following thanks to its inventor, Charles Phoenix. For Joe’s 30th celebration, I opted for a flavor profile that sounded marginally less weird: peach, apple and pecan. I call it the “Peaplecan.” It took me roughly 8 painful, long hours and I do not recommend anyone try this at home. Below, you’ll find Charles Phoenix’s orginal Cherpumple video, as well as my Peaplecan tutorial in 101 not-so-easy steps.
- You’ll need 3 boxes of store-bought cake mix
- You’ll also need 3 pies. I purchased mine to save a day’s worth of baking
- Begin by flouring a large spring-form pan
- Remove your pie from the tin…try to be more careful than me.
- Half of your batter goes in the bottom of the pan
- ….then you pop in the pie and cover with the other half of your batter
- Voila! This is the end result. Repeat the process for all three pies
- Your layers need to be flat, so you may have to do some creative shaving
- DO NOT count calories when making a Cherpumple or Peaplecan
- I prepared 4 batches of cream cheese frosting and used almost all of it
- Set down your first layer with some wax paper and frost the top
- Carefully place your second layer on top, frost again and repeat with third layer
- Refrigeration helps hold the Cherpumple or Peaplecan together!
- This is my second coat of icing, I also place skewers in the cake to keep it upright
- Sprinkles!
- My lousy attempt at cake decoration
- You have to refrigerate cream cheese frosting…you don’t want everyone getting sick
- Surprise, surprise! It’s a Peaplecan for old Joe!
- Now it’s time to taste the “Turducken of desserts”
- Moment of truth (usually these things collapse)
- Success! Peach + Apple + Pecan + Peaplecan
- Major Thomas likes the Peaplecan!
- The Marines made quite a dent in the Peaplecan, but couldn’t quite finish it…
- The Peaplecan is still upright (thanks to about 20 wooden skewers, no doubt)
- Joe better not ask for this next year…


























Holy crap! This is unbelievable. Best wife ever.
Oh, I don’t know. There’s some tough competition in our family:)
this cake looks yummy, and Joey looks like he thought it was delicious too. You really showed him the LOVE, that was allot of work girl.
________________________________
That was an amazing feat of engineering, in addition to looking DELICIOUS. Your cake decorating is actually very beautiful!
I can speak from firsthand experience…it’s sooooo good!
Thanks, Cat!!
You are the best wife ever! I’m so jealous! Happy Birthday Joey!
BB…one day your Cherpumple will come!! (hint, hint Zac)
Best wife ever! I could not be more jealous – you are so great
OMG – Heart Attack in a single bite!
I have no idea what the calorie count is, but it’s definitely NOT pretty!!